The selection of Booker Prize-winning author Banu Mushtaq to inaugurate the Dasara festivities in Mysuru has stirred controversy, with the head of the Mysuru Royal Family reportedly expressing reservations, stating the selection was not in "Dharmic spirit". This comes amidst mixed reactions online and opposition from some political figures, primarily from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).
Chief Minister Siddaramaiah of Karnataka announced Mushtaq's selection, highlighting her achievements, including winning the Booker Prize for her short story anthology "Edeya Hanatege" (Heart Lamp), and her association with the farmers' and Kannada movements. He described her as a "progressive thinker" and said the government was honoring her contributions by giving her the opportunity to inaugurate the festival. The anthology features 12 short stories that capture the daily lives of Muslim women in southern India and address patriarchy and gender inequality.
However, the decision has faced criticism, with some questioning the choice based on communal grounds. Former BJP MP Pratap Simha stated that while he respects Mushtaq's achievements, he opposed the state government's decision to have her inaugurate the Dasara festivities, questioning why a Muslim would be invited to a religious event. MLC C. T. Ravi said it was "inappropriate for a person whose faith is uncertain to preside over a religious ceremony". Another BJP leader, BY Vijayendra, questioned why the translator of Banu Mushtaq's work was not invited to the inauguration. Expelled BJP MLA Basanagouda Patil Yatnal said she should clarify her religious stance before presiding over rituals.
Amid the controversy, police in Udupi have registered two cases against individuals accused of posting provocative and communal content related to Mushtaq's selection. The posts reportedly attempted to stoke religious sentiments, prompting police action under relevant sections of the law.
Mushtaq, when contacted, declined to comment on the BJP leader's remarks but confirmed that she has been invited and will attend the event. She expressed gratitude for the invitation, viewing it as an honor not just for herself but for Kannada literature.
The Dasara festival in Mysuru is a 10-day event that attracts nearly five million people from across the globe. Over the years, the festival has also witnessed recurring disputes over its symbolism. Some Dalit and progressive groups have reinterpreted Mahishasura, who is a demon, not as a demon but as a local ruler and Buddhist reformer who was defeated and demonized in later narratives. They observe Mahisha Dasara to honor him, arguing that the mainstream festival erases indigenous and egalitarian traditions, a view opposed by some Hindu organizations.
Some argue that inviting Mushtaq is an inclusive gesture, emphasizing the festival as a celebration for all communities, irrespective of religious beliefs. Congress leader Deepak Thimaya stated that the festival should be equally celebrated by all communities. He added that Goddess Chamundeshwari embodies the spirit of Karnataka, and having a Muslim inaugurate the festival promotes inclusiveness in society.
