As the NHL offseason continues, teams are exploring various avenues to improve their rosters for the upcoming season. One intriguing idea involves the Edmonton Oilers potentially acquiring defenseman Erik Karlsson from the Pittsburgh Penguins. While it might seem odd at first glance, a TSN analyst believes this move could address a major cap issue for the Oilers.

The suggestion involves a bold trade where the Oilers would send Darnell Nurse to the Penguins in exchange for Karlsson. Nurse, a 30-year-old defenseman with a $9.2 million cap hit, has been a key part of the Oilers' defense, but his on-ice struggles, especially in the playoffs, have limited the team's cap flexibility.

Karlsson, on the other hand, is a three-time Norris Trophy winner known for his offensive prowess. Despite being 35 years old, he remains a valuable contributor, averaging 70 points per 82 games over the past three seasons. While his defensive game has been questioned, his offensive contributions at even strength and on the power play are significant.

For the Oilers, adding Karlsson could provide more offensive firepower to their already potent lineup. However, it would require careful management of Karlsson's defensive game through the right structure, defensive partner, and deployment.

Several factors make this trade idea intriguing, but also challenging.

The Oilers' Perspective

• Cap Relief: Trading Nurse would free up $9.2 million in cap space, providing the Oilers with much-needed flexibility to address other roster needs. The Oilers are strapped to the salary cap, especially with Evan Bouchard needing a new, lucrative deal. Connor McDavid is also expected to sign a contract extension, further tightening the team's financial situation.
• Offensive Boost: Karlsson's offensive abilities could elevate the Oilers' attack to another level. He could quarterback the power play and contribute significantly at even strength, playing alongside Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl.
• Defensive Concerns: Karlsson's defensive game has been a concern throughout his career. The Oilers would need to find the right defensive partner and system to maximize his strengths and minimize his weaknesses.

The Penguins' Perspective:

• Rebuilding: The Penguins are looking to rebuild and add youth to their lineup. Moving Karlsson, who has a $10 million average annual value for two more seasons, would help them acquire valuable assets.
• Matt Dumba Acquisition: The Penguins recently acquired Matt Dumba from the Dallas Stars, leading some to speculate that this move foreshadows a Karlsson trade. Mark Madden of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review believes Dumba's arrival indicates Karlsson's exit is pending.
• Karlsson's NMC: Karlsson possesses a no-movement clause, giving him control over his destination. He is reportedly willing to waive it for a few teams, particularly those that offer a chance to win the Stanley Cup.

Other Potential Suitors for Karlsson

Besides the Oilers, other teams have been linked to Karlsson, including the Toronto Maple Leafs, Carolina Hurricanes, Detroit Red Wings, and Winnipeg Jets. The Maple Leafs have been looking for another offensive-minded defenseman. The Red Wings need help on their defense and believe Karlsson could turn them into a contender.

Ultimately, whether the Oilers pursue this trade idea remains to be seen. General Manager Stan Bowman has been exploring various options to improve the team, including the goaltending market. The acquisition of Isaac Howard, a Hobey Baker Award winner, indicates a desire to get younger and change the look of the forward group.

The Karlsson trade scenario presents both opportunities and risks for the Oilers. It could provide cap relief and offensive firepower, but it also raises concerns about Karlsson's defensive game and the potential impact on team chemistry. As the offseason progresses, it will be interesting to see if this "odd" trade idea gains traction or fades away.