In the wake of Stuart Skinner's trade to the Pittsburgh Penguins on December 12, 2025, rumors swirled about a potential rift between the former Oilers goalie and team captain Connor McDavid. However, recent on-ice and off-ice interactions between the two stars seem to have quelled those speculations.

The Oilers' 6-4 victory over the Penguins on Tuesday night was filled with emotional undertones, given Skinner's recent departure. The game marked Skinner's first start with his new team against his former teammates. Amidst the competition, two instances involving McDavid and Skinner stood out, potentially putting an end to the rumors of any animosity.

The first moment occurred after McDavid scored an empty-net goal, sealing the win for Edmonton. Instead of a routine celebration, McDavid skated by Skinner and gave him a stick tap on the pads, a gesture interpreted as a sign of respect and camaraderie. This subtle acknowledgement suggested a level of understanding and support between the two players, despite the circumstances of the trade.

Beyond the on-ice encounter, reports have surfaced of two separate hugs between McDavid and Skinner outside of the game. These embraces, away from the competitive spotlight, further solidify the notion that the two players share a genuine bond.

The rumors of a strained relationship between McDavid and Skinner likely stemmed from the Oilers' recent playoff failures and Skinner's perceived struggles in net. Some observers speculated that McDavid might have harbored resentment towards Skinner for not being able to carry the team to a Stanley Cup victory. However, these recent interactions suggest otherwise.

McDavid himself addressed the rumors indirectly after the game, praising both Skinner and the Oilers' new goalie, Tristan Jarry, for how they handled themselves in the "unique situation". He acknowledged the strangeness of the night for both goalies and commended their professionalism. This statement further indicates McDavid's respect for Skinner and his desire to dispel any negativity surrounding the trade.

Skinner, for his part, has also spoken positively about his time in Edmonton and his relationship with his former teammates. He acknowledged the "noise" surrounding his performance and the trade rumors, but emphasized that he cares more about his new opportunity in Pittsburgh. He also expressed gratitude for the chance to have played alongside McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, recognizing their status as "amazing players" who will be remembered forever.

The Oilers' decision to trade Skinner was undoubtedly a difficult one, especially after Skinner helped the team reach the Stanley Cup Finals twice. McDavid admitted that the team would miss Skinner and defenseman Brett Kulak, who was also part of the trade. However, the organization felt that a change was necessary to address their goaltending issues and provide a fresh start.

While the trade may have initially raised questions about team dynamics, the recent displays of respect and affection between McDavid and Skinner suggest that their relationship remains strong. These on-camera moments and reported hugs likely put an end to the rumors of a feud, allowing both players to move forward with their respective careers.