The Montreal Canadiens' current experiment with a three-goalie system, while born out of necessity and opportunity, is unlikely to be a long-term solution for the team. The Canadiens currently have Samuel Montembeault, Jakub Dobes and Jacob Fowler on their roster. While GM Kent Hughes expressed a desire to resolve the situation internally, the complexities of managing three capable goaltenders at the NHL level present challenges that outweigh any perceived benefits.

The initial catalyst for this situation was a combination of factors. Montembeault, the Canadiens' incumbent number one, has struggled with consistency this season, posting a .857 save percentage. This opened the door for both Dobes and Fowler to prove themselves. Fowler, in particular, has seized the opportunity, even recording a shutout in only his fourth contest.

While a three-goalie system might seem to foster internal competition and keep netminders fresh, its practical application often leads to instability and inconsistent performance. Goalies thrive on rhythm and routine, and the uncertainty of playing time in a three-goalie rotation can disrupt their focus and negatively impact their development. The situation can be hard to manage for the team's coaching staff.

Furthermore, carrying three goalies on the active roster occupies valuable roster spots that could be used to bolster other areas of the team. The Canadiens would benefit more from utilizing those spots to develop young forwards or defensemen or to acquire veteran depth to support their playoff push.

So, what is the solution? The Canadiens need to make a decision and commit to a tandem of two goalies. Samuel Montembeault was sent to Laval for conditioning. The team needs to decide if Montembeault can regain his form. Fowler's strong start is putting pressure on management to keep him in the NHL. Jakub Dobes has also played well.

Several options exist. The Canadiens could trade either Dobes or Montembeault, providing them with assets to address other needs. Another option involves sending Fowler back to the Laval Rocket to continue his development in a less pressurized environment, allowing Montembeault and Dobes to form the NHL tandem. However, Fowler has performed well enough that sending him back to the minors "does not make sense".

The Canadiens may want to look to Samuel Montembeault for stability. He is expected to join the team after Christmas.

Ultimately, the Canadiens' experiment with a three-goalie system is a temporary measure. For the long-term success of the team and the individual development of their goaltenders, a clear and decisive resolution is required.