MacKenzie Weegar's performance with the Calgary Flames has been a topic of much discussion and scrutiny since his arrival in Calgary. Acquired in a trade with the Florida Panthers in July 2022, expectations were high for the veteran defenseman. However, his journey with the Flames has been marked by inconsistency, leading to questions about his fit and overall impact on the team.

Weegar's offensive production has been a key area of focus. While he had a solid 47-point campaign in 2024-25, it proved difficult to duplicate his 20-goal performance from the previous season. His drop to eight goals in 2024-25 raised concerns that his 20-goal season might have been an outlier. Despite his offensive struggles at times, Weegar has shown flashes of brilliance, including a hat trick against the New York Islanders in February 2024, becoming the first Flames defenseman to achieve a regular-season road hat trick since 1975.

Defensively, Weegar's contributions have been more consistent. He leads all Flames defensemen in both hits and blocks. In a game against the Chicago Blackhawks in January 2026, Weegar sacrificed his body, blocking crucial shots to help seal a 3-1 victory.

Despite his efforts, Weegar has expressed frustration with his offensive stat line and plus-minus. At 32 years old (as of January 2026), he is aware of the need to contribute in all areas of the game. Although he had a rough start to the year, his performance improved in December 2025, earning nine points in the last 10 games of the month.

The Flames' acquisition of prospect Zayne Parekh, known for his offensive capabilities, could impact Weegar's power-play usage in the future. To maintain his value to the team, Weegar will need to increase his production at even strength.

Throughout his time in Calgary, Weegar has proven to be a reliable player, missing only two games in his three-year tenure. He has also been effective at quarterbacking the top power play, accumulating 36 power-play points over the past two seasons.

Looking ahead, Weegar's ability to adapt and contribute consistently will be crucial for the Flames. As the team navigates its future, Weegar's performance will continue to be a focal point for fans and analysts alike.