Jonathan Toews' return to the NHL with the Winnipeg Jets has been anything but simple, despite the heartwarming narrative of a hometown hero coming back. After a 15-year career with the Chicago Blackhawks, marked by three Stanley Cups, a Conn Smythe Trophy, and a Selke Trophy, Toews stepped away from the game to address health concerns, including Chronic Inflammatory Response Syndrome and long COVID. He sat out for two seasons before signing with the Jets in the summer of 2025.

The homecoming was supposed to be a dream come true, with the Winnipeg native donning the jersey he grew up watching. However, the reality has been more complex. While Toews has been contributing with improved play recently, including a notable return to Chicago where he received a thunderous ovation from Blackhawks fans, the Jets' overall performance has cast a shadow. As of late January 2026, the team's struggles have led to questions about Toews' role and future with the team.

The question of whether the Jets should trade Toews is now being raised. On paper, he is a rental player since he is only signed for the current season. However, his value to Winnipeg transcends typical trade considerations due to his local roots and legacy. His contract includes playoff and performance bonuses that further complicate any potential trade.

Despite the logistical challenges, Toews could still be a valuable addition to a contender, offering depth and leadership. The human element further complicates the situation. His return to Chicago was a deeply emotional event, underscoring his importance beyond statistics. He represents leadership, memory, and a presence that impacts the atmosphere of a team.

Toews himself has expressed a desire to prove he still has something to offer after what he felt was an unsatisfactory end to his time in Chicago. "I'm not satisfied with the way things ended in Chicago," Toews said. "It's not about proving anything. It's just that there's something left in the tank, and I want to explore that".

Ultimately, the decision regarding Toews' future with the Jets involves balancing loyalty, ambition, finances, and legacy. As the trade deadline approaches, the Jets face a difficult choice: hold onto a beloved local player or capitalize on his value to improve the team's long-term prospects. Regardless of the outcome, Toews' return to Winnipeg has been a significant chapter in his career, filled with both promise and unforeseen challenges.