Pakistan's cricket scene is currently witnessing intense scrutiny following a string of disappointing performances in 2025. The team's struggles have ignited debates among former players and analysts, with Waqar Younis emerging as a prominent voice urging significant changes. Recent performances have led to calls for a major shakeup in the team's composition, with Younis specifically suggesting that certain underperforming players need to be dropped to pave the way for fresh talent.
Younis's critique comes at a critical juncture for Pakistan cricket. The team's performance in ODIs this year has been dismal, recording the lowest win percentage in its history. In 11 matches played in 2025, Pakistan has only managed to secure two victories, resulting in a win percentage of a mere 18.18%. This poor form has raised concerns about the team's competitiveness and its ability to qualify for the 2027 ODI World Cup.
Adding to the woes, Pakistan suffered a defeat against India in the Asia Cup 2025, further exposing the widening gap between the two sides. The loss highlighted the team's lack of strategic depth and adaptability, with the middle-order batting and bowling crumbling under pressure. This performance prompted Mohsin Naqvi's remark that the team needed "major surgery," but one year later, Pakistan seems to have regressed.
Waqar Younis's call for dropping a star player underscores the urgent need for Pakistan to address its shortcomings. While he didn't name a specific player in reports, his comments came after Pakistan barely secured a win against Bangladesh in the Asia Cup 2025. Younis questioned the continued backing of Saim Ayub, suggesting the youngster could benefit from a break. Pakistan's victory against Bangladesh, securing their place in the Asia Cup final against India, was hard-fought. Despite restricting Bangladesh to a low score, Pakistan's batting also struggled, and Younis pointed out that the team wouldn't have even made 100 runs if Bangladesh had capitalized on dropped catches.
It's important to note that Younis's analysis isn't the first time he's been embroiled in controversy regarding team selection and player performance. In the past, Younis has faced criticism for his decisions as a coach and selector, with some accusing him of being "arrogant" and "revengeful". He has also been at the center of controversy for comments made that mixed religion and sports, for which he later apologized.
The former coach has emphasized the importance of developing new talent and not compromising on training and fitness. He believes that Pakistan cricket can only move forward by investing in younger players who bring energy and better fielding standards to the team. Younis has also stated that senior players should retire gracefully instead of lingering on and that the squad needs a definite shape.
The situation demands decisive action from the Pakistan management. While securing a spot in the Asia Cup final offers a chance for redemption, the underlying issues need to be addressed to ensure long-term success. Whether the management will heed Waqar Younis's advice and make the necessary changes remains to be seen. However, one thing is clear: Pakistan cricket needs a new direction to regain its competitive edge and restore the faith of its fans.
