The Asia Cup 2025 final between India and Pakistan in Dubai was filled with controversial moments involving India's captain, Suryakumar Yadav. These incidents ranged from an appeal for obstructing the field to a disputed catch and perceived breaches of sportsmanship, drawing criticism from fans and commentators alike.
One of the most debated incidents occurred during Pakistan's innings when Suryakumar appealed for obstructing the field against Pakistan's captain, Salman Ali Agha. Agha played a shot towards extra cover and took off for a run. Suryakumar collected the ball and threw it towards the striker's end in an attempt to run Agha out, but the ball hit Agha while he was completing the second run. Suryakumar immediately appealed, but the third umpire ruled that Agha had not deliberately changed his running path and was therefore not out.
The decision sparked debate, with some fans and former cricketers like Wasim Akram questioning Suryakumar's sportsmanship. Akram stated, "Where is sportsman spirit? Made no sense to appeal". However, others felt Suryakumar was simply trying to win the game and utilized the rules.
Adding to the controversy, Suryakumar Yadav's dismissal in the final also stirred debate. Chasing 147, India lost early wickets, including Suryakumar, who was caught by Salman Agha off Shaheen Afridi's bowling. Some fans felt the catch was controversial, questioning whether it was clean.
Further controversy arose from Suryakumar's actions before the match. Following India's "No Handshake policy" against Pakistan in the tournament, Suryakumar again skipped the customary handshake with Salman Agha at the toss. He also refused to participate in the customary pre-final photoshoot with the Pakistan captain. When asked about Suryakumar's refusal to participate in the photoshoot, Salman Agha responded, "It is completely his call, whether he wants to come or not. I can't do anything in that".
Suryakumar defended his earlier decision not to shake hands, stating that "some things in life are bigger than sportsman's spirit," showing solidarity with victims of the Pahalgam attack. However, these actions, combined with his appeal for obstructing the field, led to criticism and accusations of unsportsmanlike behavior.
Adding to the woes, Suryakumar's recent batting form has been a concern. Sunil Gavaskar has been particularly critical, questioning Suryakumar's shot selection and decision-making. Gavaskar also criticized the team management's decision to alter the batting order, suggesting Suryakumar should have batted higher to regain his form.
The Asia Cup 2025 final highlighted the intense rivalry between India and Pakistan and also raised questions about Suryakumar Yadav's conduct as captain. His actions, both on and off the field, drew mixed reactions, with some defending his competitive spirit and others criticizing his sportsmanship.
