Kerala Consumer Court: Gravy with Porotta Not a Legal Right; Complaint Dismissed Based on Obligation.
  • 497 views
  • 2 min read

The Ernakulam District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (DCDRC) has dismissed a complaint filed by a consumer who claimed a restaurant failed to serve complimentary gravy with his order of porotta and beef fry. The ruling emphasizes that restaurants have no legal or contractual obligation to provide gravy, and thus, not providing it does not constitute a deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. This verdict offers clarity for restaurants and consumers alike, establishing that gravy is not an automatic entitlement.

The case, Shibu S. Vayalakath v. Manager, The Persian Table Restaurant & ors, arose when Shibu S. Vayalakath, a journalist, visited The Persian Table restaurant in Kolenchery with a friend in November of last year. After ordering porotta and beef fry, a staple dish in Kerala, he requested gravy, which the restaurant refused, citing its policy. Dissatisfied, Vayalakath filed a complaint with the Kunnathunadu Taluk Supply Officer. A joint inquiry by the Taluk Supply Officer and the Food Safety Officer confirmed that the restaurant did not include gravy as part of its menu offerings.

Subsequently, Vayalakath approached the consumer forum seeking ₹1 lakh in compensation for emotional distress and mental agony, along with ₹10,000 for legal costs and action against the restaurant. He argued that denying gravy constituted a restrictive trade practice and a deficiency in service, further claiming the restaurant violated food safety standards by serving an "incomplete meal".

The consumer court, however, found no merit in his arguments. Presided over by President DB Binu and members Ramachandran V and Sreevidhia TN, the commission observed that Vayalakath did not raise any concerns regarding the quality, quantity, or safety of the food. His complaint solely pertained to the non-availability of gravy, which was neither promised nor charged for.

The commission stated, "In the instant case, there was no contractual obligation express or implied on the part of the Opposite Party to provide gravy. Therefore, the non-providing of gravy at the time of supplying porotta and beef cannot be considered as a deficiency in service from the part of opposite party No.1 and 2, and hence no enforceable consumer relationship arises in this respect." They further clarified that a restaurant's internal policy regarding accompaniments, in the absence of a legal or contractual obligation, cannot be construed as a deficiency in service.

The restaurant owner expressed relief at the verdict, stating that providing free gravy to every customer would increase operational costs and impact the business's sustainability. He also recounted that Vayalakath initially did not ask for gravy but requested it later and became argumentative when the restaurant clarified its policy.

This ruling clarifies that customers cannot demand gravy as a right when visiting hotels and restaurants. It reaffirms that restaurants have the autonomy to set their own policies regarding complimentary items, as long as there is no misrepresentation or deceptive trade practice. The Ernakulam District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission dismissed the complaint, underscoring that the failure to serve free gravy with beef fry and porotta did not violate consumer rights.


Writer - Isha Sharma
Passionate about culture, society, and sports, Isha brings a fresh, insightful perspective to her early journalism. She's keen on exploring her city's evolving cultural landscape, covering local arts, music, and community events. Isha is developing an engaging, informative writing style to capture artistic vibrancy and diversity. She's also interested in how cultural trends reflect and influence broader social dynamics, alongside her enthusiasm for the world of sports.
Advertisement

Latest Post


Sports  |  Aug 18, 2025
A recent video clip of Philadelphia Flyers' rising star Matvei Michkov expressing his dislike for the "dump and chase" style of hockey has stirred up a playful clash with the team's new head coach, Rick Tocchet. The 20-year-old Michkov, known for his...

Sports  |  Aug 18, 2025
Wayne Rooney has voiced his strong opinions on the persistent issue of racism in football, recounting a distressing experience during his time managing DC United in Major League Soccer. Speaking on his new BBC podcast, "The Wayne Rooney Show," the fo...

World  |  Aug 18, 2025
The Samajwadi Party (SP) is escalating its conflict with the Election Commission of India (ECI), accusing the poll body of inaction regarding alleged voter list irregularities during the 2022 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections. The SP has produced copi...

Sports  |  Aug 18, 2025
The Edmonton Oilers have been actively exploring the European market to bolster their forward depth, particularly after signing David Tomasek. While Tomasek is expected to compete for a spot on the NHL roster, reports indicate that the Oilers also co...

Advertisement
Entertainment  |  Aug 18, 2025
Taylor Swift has once again demonstrated her unparalleled influence in the music industry, this time with the rapid sell-out of the vinyl variants for her upcoming album, "The Life Of A Showgirl". The new variants, unveiled on Monday, August 18th, we...

Technology  |  Aug 18, 2025
Sherrod Brown, who recently served as a United States Senator for Ohio from 2007 to 2025, has announced his candidacy for the 2026 special election in Ohio. Brown, a Democrat, is seeking to reclaim a Senate seat after losing his re-election bid in 20...

World  |  Aug 18, 2025
The Rajya Sabha experienced a day of disruption on Monday as the Opposition staged a walkout over the issue of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar. Despite the turmoil, the government successfully pushed through the India...

World  |  Aug 18, 2025
A controversy has erupted in Assam over a question included in a recent Agricultural Development Officer (ADO) examination regarding the Manipur crisis, specifically concerning the absence of any mention of Kuki militants in the answer choices. The A...

Advertisement

About   •   Terms   •   Privacy
© 2025 DailyDigest360