Allahabad HC Acquits Man Deemed Mentally Ill After 23 Years; Wrongly Accused of Killing Wife and Son.
  • 705 views
  • 2 min read

In a significant ruling delivered on May 29, 2025, the Allahabad High Court overturned the conviction of a man who had been serving a life sentence for the murder of his wife and son. The court, after a thorough examination of the evidence, concluded that the accused was suffering from impaired mental health at the time of the crime, thus invoking the general exception under Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). This decision brings to a close a legal battle that spanned over two decades, highlighting the complexities of cases involving mental illness and the law.

The case originated from an incident that occurred on the night of August 31 and September 1, 2002, in the Fakharpur Police Station area of Bahraich district. According to the First Information Report (FIR) filed by the accused's father, Prahlad Kumar Tewari, Rajesh @ Sajesh Tewari, had been suffering from mental illness for more than a year. It was alleged that Rajesh, using a sharp-edged weapon, murdered his wife and son, Durgesh, in the early hours of the morning. Initially, the FIR was registered under Section 304 IPC (culpable homicide not amounting to murder), but later, charges were framed under Section 302 IPC (murder).

In 2005, the Additional Sessions Judge/Fast Track Court No. 1, Bahraich, found Rajesh guilty under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to life imprisonment, along with a fine of ₹20,000. Failure to pay the fine would result in an additional two years of simple imprisonment. This conviction led Rajesh to file an appeal in the Allahabad High Court, challenging the lower court's judgment.

The defense presented before the High Court centered on Rajesh's long history of neurological and psychiatric treatment. Medical prescriptions dating back to February 2002 from Jamuna Neuro Psychiatric Centre were submitted as evidence. The defense argued that Rajesh lacked the necessary mens rea (guilty mind) at the time of the incident due to his unsound mind and was therefore entitled to protection under Section 84 IPC, which exempts individuals of unsound mind from criminal liability.

The Division Bench of Justice Sangeeta Chandra and Justice Shree Prakash Singh, after reviewing the evidence and arguments, concluded that Rajesh's impaired mental condition was evident. The court noted that the prosecution witnesses' statements, along with the medical records, sufficiently established that Rajesh was suffering from a mental impairment at the time of the crime. Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the conviction and acquitting Rajesh of all charges. The court stated, "The overall examination of the evidences including the statements of the prosecution witnesses, is enough to establish that the appellant was suffering with certain impaired mental condition and thus, the instant matter obviously, falls in a category of general exception.”

This verdict underscores the importance of considering mental health in legal proceedings. Section 84 IPC provides a crucial safeguard for individuals whose actions are driven by mental illness, recognizing that they should not be held criminally responsible for acts committed without a sound mind. The Allahabad High Court's decision emphasizes the need for a careful and comprehensive evaluation of evidence related to an accused's mental state, ensuring that justice is served while also protecting the rights of those with mental health conditions. The case serves as a reminder that mental illness can significantly impact a person's actions and culpability, and the legal system must account for these factors.


Writer - Nikhil Khan
Nikhil Khan is a promising journalist, eager to contribute fresh perspectives to the media landscape. With a strong interest in current affairs and a dedication to journalistic integrity, along with a deep passion for sports, Nikhil focuses on delivering well-researched and engaging content. He's committed to exploring diverse topics and aims to bring important stories to light for a wide audience. His love for sports also fuels his competitive drive for impactful reporting.
Advertisement

Latest Post


Sports  |  Aug 18, 2025
A recent video clip of Philadelphia Flyers' rising star Matvei Michkov expressing his dislike for the "dump and chase" style of hockey has stirred up a playful clash with the team's new head coach, Rick Tocchet. The 20-year-old Michkov, known for his...

Sports  |  Aug 18, 2025
Wayne Rooney has voiced his strong opinions on the persistent issue of racism in football, recounting a distressing experience during his time managing DC United in Major League Soccer. Speaking on his new BBC podcast, "The Wayne Rooney Show," the fo...

World  |  Aug 18, 2025
The Samajwadi Party (SP) is escalating its conflict with the Election Commission of India (ECI), accusing the poll body of inaction regarding alleged voter list irregularities during the 2022 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections. The SP has produced copi...

Sports  |  Aug 18, 2025
The Edmonton Oilers have been actively exploring the European market to bolster their forward depth, particularly after signing David Tomasek. While Tomasek is expected to compete for a spot on the NHL roster, reports indicate that the Oilers also co...

Advertisement
Entertainment  |  Aug 18, 2025
Taylor Swift has once again demonstrated her unparalleled influence in the music industry, this time with the rapid sell-out of the vinyl variants for her upcoming album, "The Life Of A Showgirl". The new variants, unveiled on Monday, August 18th, we...

Technology  |  Aug 18, 2025
Sherrod Brown, who recently served as a United States Senator for Ohio from 2007 to 2025, has announced his candidacy for the 2026 special election in Ohio. Brown, a Democrat, is seeking to reclaim a Senate seat after losing his re-election bid in 20...

World  |  Aug 18, 2025
The Rajya Sabha experienced a day of disruption on Monday as the Opposition staged a walkout over the issue of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar. Despite the turmoil, the government successfully pushed through the India...

World  |  Aug 18, 2025
A controversy has erupted in Assam over a question included in a recent Agricultural Development Officer (ADO) examination regarding the Manipur crisis, specifically concerning the absence of any mention of Kuki militants in the answer choices. The A...

Advertisement

About   •   Terms   •   Privacy
© 2025 DailyDigest360