Lionel Messi, at nearly 38 years old, stepped onto the pitch at Hard Rock Stadium in Miami on Saturday, June 14, 2025, not just as a player, but as a symbol of both the allure and the controversy surrounding the newly expanded FIFA Club World Cup. Inter Miami's opening match against Egyptian giants Al Ahly, a 0-0 draw, offered glimpses of Messi's enduring genius, even as the tournament itself faces scrutiny for its format, scheduling, and perceived motives.

The revamped Club World Cup, now featuring 32 teams instead of the traditional seven, is FIFA President Gianni Infantino's vision to reshape global football. The tournament, held in the United States from June 14 to July 13, 2025, brings together club champions from around the world, promising a spectacle of talent and competition. However, the expansion has been met with criticism from various quarters.

One major point of contention is the increased strain on players. FIFPro, the global players' union, has voiced concerns about the demanding schedule, potentially forcing the winning team to play seven additional games after an already extended season. This concern is amplified by the fact that many players have already participated in grueling domestic and international campaigns.

The tournament's scheduling has also drawn flak, with some critics arguing that it disrupts the traditional football calendar and encroaches on players' rest periods. The Club World Cup takes place during the summer, a time usually reserved for player recuperation before the start of the new season.

Furthermore, there are accusations that the expanded Club World Cup is primarily a "cash grab" by FIFA. Critics like journalist Henry Bushnell have suggested that the tournament is an attempt to monetize football's biggest clubs and players, driven by a power struggle between Infantino and UEFA President Aleksander Ceferin. This perception is fueled by the substantial $1 billion prize money on offer, raising questions about the true motivations behind the tournament's revamp.

Adding to the controversy, FIFA's decision to award Inter Miami a spot in the tournament has been questioned. Despite not winning the MLS Cup, Inter Miami was granted a "host country" slot, a move widely seen as a way to ensure Messi's participation and boost the tournament's appeal. This decision has led to accusations of undermining the tournament's "merit-based" legitimacy.

Despite the controversies, Messi's presence undoubtedly adds a layer of excitement and star power to the Club World Cup. His debut match, though ending in a goalless draw, showcased his ability to inspire and create opportunities. In the second half, Messi led a strong resurgence, with a long-range effort hitting the bar, demonstrating his enduring quality and determination.

Ultimately, the 2025 FIFA Club World Cup is a complex event, fraught with controversy yet brimming with potential. Whether it lives up to its promise of showcasing the best of club football remains to be seen, but with Messi on the stage, glimpses of genius are all but guaranteed.