The Edmonton Oilers are facing intense scrutiny following a series of roster decisions that have left many questioning the team's direction and ability to contend for the Stanley Cup. After two consecutive Stanley Cup Final losses to the Florida Panthers, the pressure is mounting on General Manager Stan Bowman to make strategic moves that will improve the team. However, recent trades, free agency signings, and departures have sparked debate and raised concerns about the Oilers' long-term prospects.
One of the most notable moves was the signing of left winger Andrew Mangiapane to a two-year contract with an average annual value of $3.6 million. While Mangiapane brings speed and some offensive capabilities to the team, his arrival has been met with mixed reactions. Some view him as a decent depth signing who can contribute in the bottom six and on the penalty kill. Others question whether he is the right fit to replace the production lost from departing players.
Indeed, the Oilers have experienced a significant roster turnover in the past year. Key contributors such as Ryan McLeod, Philip Broberg, Dylan Holloway, and Cody Ceci have all moved on. Veterans like Corey Perry and Connor Brown have also found new homes, while Evander Kane was traded to the Vancouver Canucks and Viktor Arvidsson to the Boston Bruins. Additionally, Jeff Skinner and John Klingberg were not re-signed. This mass exodus has led to concerns about the team's depth and overall talent level.
The departure of Kane, in particular, has stirred controversy, with some questioning the legitimacy of his Long-Term Injured Reserve (LTIR) designation. An NHL investigation into the matter has raised concerns about potential salary cap manipulation and the integrity of the league's roster management system.
The Oilers' goaltending situation is also under the microscope. After inconsistent performances from Stuart Skinner in the Stanley Cup Final, even franchise icon Wayne Gretzky publicly questioned the team's "unforgivable" goalie decisions. Gretzky emphasized the need for a solidified netminder and criticized the team's unstable rotation.
Despite these challenges, Bowman has made some additions to the roster. The acquisition of Jake Walman is expected to bolster the defense, and there are high hopes for young players like Matthew Savoie. However, questions remain about whether these moves will be enough to offset the losses and propel the Oilers to a championship.
The pressure on Mangiapane is particularly high, as he is seen as one of the key replacements for the departed forwards. He will need to demonstrate consistency and contribute offensively to justify his acquisition. Coach Kris Knoblauch has shown a willingness to give players opportunities based on their skating ability and pressure on the ice, which could benefit Mangiapane.
Ultimately, the success of the Oilers' roster decisions will depend on several factors, including Mangiapane's performance, the development of young players, and the team's ability to address its goaltending concerns. As the Oilers look ahead to the 2025-26 season, they face the challenge of proving that they can still compete for the Stanley Cup despite the recent changes and criticisms. The pressure is on Bowman and the entire organization to demonstrate that they have a clear vision and the ability to execute it.
