Dan Muse's inaugural season as head coach of the Pittsburgh Penguins is marked by both optimism and considerable challenges. Named the 23rd head coach in franchise history on June 4, 2025, Muse, at just 42 years old, brings a unique blend of youth and experience to the role. He replaces Mike Sullivan, inheriting a team in transition, balancing veteran superstars with the need for a rebuild.
Muse's coaching journey is noteworthy. Prior to joining the Penguins, he served as an assistant coach with the New York Rangers for two seasons. However, he has prior head coaching experience in the USHL, notably with the Chicago Steel, where he led the team to its first-ever Clark Cup in 2017. He also guided the U.S. National Team Development Program (NTDP), leading the U18 team to a gold medal at the 2023 IIHF World Championship. His time with the NTDP saw him coach future NHL players like Ryan Leonard, Will Smith, and Luke Hughes.
General Manager Kyle Dubas has expressed optimism about Muse, citing his background in player development as a key asset. Muse's track record demonstrates an ability to develop players while also achieving success, a crucial combination for the Penguins as they look to integrate promising prospects into the lineup.
One of Muse's immediate priorities is addressing the team's defensive struggles. Last season, the Penguins ranked near the bottom of the NHL in key defensive metrics. Veteran defensemen Kris Letang and Erik Karlsson, while potentially Hall of Fame-bound, have not consistently performed at their peak. The acquisition of Matt Dumba could bring some physicality to the blue line. A key focus will be on the development of young players like Owen Pickering, who is vying for a permanent spot on the roster. Muse has already singled out prospect forward Ben Kindel for praise after a strong showing in training camp. Kindel, drafted 11th overall by the Penguins in the 2025 NHL Entry Draft, has impressed Muse with his hockey sense and positioning.
Goaltender Tristan Jarry is also under pressure to improve. After signing a five-year contract in 2023, Jarry's performance has been inconsistent, leading to multiple demotions to the AHL last season. While defensive improvements should help, Jarry needs to regain his form to solidify his role as the starting goaltender.
Marc Johnstone, a forward with the Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Penguins, who played under Muse with the Chicago Steel, describes Muse as a "player's coach" who expects a lot from his players. Johnstone recalls Muse's attention to detail, use of video analysis, and the way he made practices more demanding than the games. He also emphasizes Muse's ability to connect with players on a personal level, fostering a strong team environment.
Despite the challenges, Muse's track record suggests he is well-equipped to handle the task. His experience in developing young talent, combined with his success in implementing effective defensive systems, could be the key to turning the Penguins around. While immediate Cup contention may be unrealistic, success for Muse in his first season could be defined by the development of young players, improved defensive play, and a resurgence in Tristan Jarry's performance.
