The debate is raging: Connor McDavid or Nathan MacKinnon for the Hart Trophy? As the 2025-26 NHL season approaches its midpoint, fans and analysts are locked in a heated discussion about which of these two superstars is most deserving of the league's MVP award.
McDavid, the Edmonton Oilers' captain, and MacKinnon, the Colorado Avalanche's dynamic center, have both elevated their games to new heights this season. They are currently the top two point producers in the league, propelling their teams to comfortable playoff positions. McDavid has accumulated 67 points (23 goals, 44 assists) in 38 games, while MacKinnon has 61 points (30 goals, 31 assists) in 36 games.
MacKinnon started the season strong, leading many to believe he had a lock on the Hart and Art Ross Trophies. However, McDavid shifted into "McJesus" mode in December, closing the gap and surpassing MacKinnon in the scoring race.
TSN's OverDrive conducted a poll on X, asking whether McDavid was more likely to win the Hart Trophy than MacKinnon, with 56% of over 750 voters affirming. The debate highlights the difficulty in choosing between two generational talents at the peak of their abilities.
McDavid, standing at 6'1" and weighing 194 lbs, has a decorated career, including three Hart Trophies, five Art Ross Trophies, and the Conn Smythe Trophy. The 28 year old center is known for his exceptional skating, puck-handling skills, and playmaking abilities.
MacKinnon, at 6'0" and 200 lbs, won the Hart Trophy in 2024. The 30 year old is renowned for his speed, powerful shot, and relentless competitiveness.
Several factors could influence the final decision. Both players have elite teammates, such as Leon Draisaitl and Cale Makar, who could also garner Hart Trophy consideration. McDavid's recent performance in leading the Oilers back into contention, despite a thinner supporting cast, gives him a slight edge. However, MacKinnon's consistent dominance and the Avalanche's league-leading performance cannot be ignored.
Ultimately, the Professional Hockey Writers Association will determine the winner of the Hart Trophy. The award is presented annually to the player judged most valuable to his team. The winner will be announced at the 2025 NHL Awards show on June 12th.
While the debate continues, one thing is certain: both Connor McDavid and Nathan MacKinnon are exceptional players who have left an indelible mark on the game. Their outstanding performances this season have provided fans with a thrilling MVP race that will be closely watched until the very end.
