As Connor McDavid approaches free agency, the Edmonton Oilers face mounting pressure to secure their captain's future. With the season drawing near and no contract extension in place, speculation about potential trade destinations and blockbuster offers is intensifying.
The Athletic recently tasked its league writers with proposing scenarios for how their respective teams might attempt to acquire McDavid. The hypothetical offers ranged from creative to outlandish. Cory Lavalette of The Athletic proposed a package from the Carolina Hurricanes that included three first-round picks, Andrei Svechnikov, prospect Bradly Nadeau, and goalie Pyotr Kochetkov. Lavalette admitted that even this substantial offer "still might not be enough".
Other teams focused on lifestyle and marketability. The Anaheim Ducks pitched the idea of McDavid enjoying golf with Teemu Selanne and surfing with Paul Kariya, all while escaping the intense scrutiny of the Alberta media. The Calgary Flames leaned into the rivalry, suggesting McDavid embrace a "dark side" storyline by joining Edmonton's most hated opponent. The Dallas Stars emphasized tax breaks, a reliable goalie in Jake Oettinger, and a general manager with a history with McDavid from his junior hockey days.
Some teams focused on spectacle. The Columbus Blue Jackets offered a barrage of cannon blasts, while the Boston Bruins teased the potential for "future McDavids" due to the city's numerous colleges. The Nashville Predators dangled country music cameos and nights out with Morgan Wallen. The Toronto Maple Leafs, McDavid's childhood team, presented a simple pitch: come home, play alongside Auston Matthews, and end the franchise's Stanley Cup drought.
While the Oilers remain publicly confident in their ability to re-sign McDavid, the lack of an agreement has fueled concerns. NHL insider Greg Wyshynski suggested McDavid might prefer a shorter extension, aligning his contract with those of Ryan Nugent-Hopkins and Evan Bouchard. This would put pressure on Oilers General Manager Stan Bowman to build a championship-caliber team quickly. Some believe McDavid's next contract could be less than expected, potentially around $15.5 million per year.
Elliotte Friedman of the "32 Thoughts" podcast believes a deal could be reached before the season starts, ending the speculation. Friedman also noted that several NHL front offices are hoping McDavid signs for a slightly lower figure, which could influence other contract negotiations around the league.
The Oilers' performance in the upcoming season will likely play a significant role in McDavid's decision. After a heartbreaking loss to the Florida Panthers in the Stanley Cup Final, McDavid is determined to win a championship. The team's ability to contend for a title will weigh heavily on his choice. Edmonton is reportedly looking to acquire a scoring winger to play alongside McDavid and Leon Draisaitl before the trade deadline to improve their chances.
McDavid's decision could have a ripple effect across the NHL. If he leaves Edmonton, it could encourage other superstars to consider changing teams. A team-friendly deal could alter how stars negotiate contracts, while a maximum-value contract could reset the market.
