The Indiana Pacers and New York Knicks boast a rivalry etched in NBA playoff lore, a series of dramatic encounters that have produced unforgettable moments of brilliance, controversy, and sheer intensity. Meeting 8 times in the playoffs since 1993, these clashes have been defined by iconic players, heated battles, and a genuine animosity that captivated fans. As they prepare to face off once again in the 2025 Eastern Conference Finals, it's time to relive some of the most memorable chapters in this storied rivalry.
One of the earliest flashpoints occurred in the 1993 Eastern Conference First Round. With the Knicks leading the series 2-0 and aiming for a sweep, Pacers guard Reggie Miller found himself at odds with John Starks. Frustration boiled over when Starks, believing Miller was getting away with fouls, retaliated with a headbutt that led to his ejection. The Pacers capitalized, winning the game and igniting a rivalry that would only intensify in the years to come.
The 1994 Eastern Conference Finals provided a defining moment in the rivalry, showcasing Reggie Miller's clutch gene and his penchant for antagonizing Knicks fans. In Game 5 at Madison Square Garden, with the series tied 2-2, the Knicks held a comfortable lead heading into the fourth quarter. However, Miller exploded for 25 points in the final frame, leading the Pacers to a stunning comeback victory. During his scoring barrage, Miller infamously flashed a "choke" sign towards Knicks superfan Spike Lee, forever cementing his status as a villain in New York. Although the Knicks would go on to win the series, the Miller-Lee feud became a captivating sideshow that transcended the court.
Just a year later, in the 1995 Eastern Conference Semifinals, Miller delivered another gut-wrenching blow to Knicks fans. Game 1 at Madison Square Garden witnessed one of the most improbable comebacks in NBA history. Trailing by six points with just 18.7 seconds remaining, Miller scored eight points in a mere nine seconds, hitting a 3-pointer, stealing the inbounds pass for another 3-pointer, and then sinking two free throws after being fouled. This remarkable sequence propelled the Pacers to an improbable victory, leaving the Knicks and their fans in disbelief. Miller himself said after the game, "Mason choked and threw it to me, I hit a 3, and we almost cost us the game when Sam (Mitchell) made that foul, but John Starks choked and we came up big."
While Miller often played the role of antagonist, other Knicks players also contributed memorable moments. In Game 3 of the 1999 Eastern Conference Finals, with the Knicks trailing the Pacers 91-88, Larry Johnson hit a game-winning four-point play, sinking a 3-pointer while being fouled by Antonio Davis. Johnson converted the free throw, giving the Knicks a 92-91 victory and helping them advance to the NBA Finals as an eighth seed.
More recently, in Game 7 of the 2024 Eastern Conference Semifinals, the Pacers delivered a record-breaking offensive performance at Madison Square Garden, shooting 67.1% from the field in their 130-109 victory. Tyrese Haliburton led the way with 26 points and added insult to injury by wearing a sweatshirt depicting Miller's choke sign towards Spike Lee during his postgame press conference.
These are just a few of the many iconic moments that have defined the Pacers-Knicks rivalry. The series has been a constant source of drama, excitement, and unforgettable plays. As they face off in the 2025 Eastern Conference Finals, fans can expect another chapter filled with passion, intensity, and perhaps a few more moments that will be replayed for years to come. With stars like Jalen Brunson and Tyrese Haliburton now leading the charge, this rivalry is set to continue captivating audiences and adding to its already rich history.
