Gabe Perreault, the New York Rangers' top prospect, has generated considerable buzz, and the question on many fans' minds is whether he should start the season in the top six. Selected 23rd overall in the 2023 NHL Entry Draft, Perreault signed a three-year, entry-level contract with the Rangers in March 2025 after two impressive seasons at Boston College.

Perreault's collegiate performance speaks volumes about his potential. In 73 games with Boston College, the right-winger amassed 108 points (35 goals and 73 assists). During his freshman year (2023-24), he recorded 19 goals and 41 assists, totaling 60 points, and was recognized as a CCM/AHCA Second Team All-American and a Hockey East Second Team All-Star. In his sophomore season, he continued to excel, scoring 16 goals and 32 assists for 48 points in 37 games. Before college, Perreault also shone with the USA Hockey National Team Development Program, where he accumulated 185 points (71 goals and 114 assists) in 121 games. His assist and point totals rank fourth all-time in the program's history. Moreover, he boasts a winning pedigree, with gold medals at the 2024 and 2025 World Junior Championships and the 2023 U-18 World Championship.

Perreault made his NHL debut on April 2, 2025, against the Minnesota Wild. He played in five games, and while he didn't register any points, he demonstrated flashes of his potential. Despite his promising start, he was surprisingly scratched after a few appearances, which some observers felt was a missed opportunity for further development.

There are compelling arguments for integrating Perreault into the Rangers' top six. He is considered the Rangers' most skilled forward prospect, with exceptional hockey sense and playmaking abilities. Prior to the 2024-25 season, he was rated as the Rangers' best prospect, praised for his vision and hockey sense. He has a knack for getting pucks to sticks and is a brilliant playmaker. His offensive talent is undeniable, and his hockey IQ suggests he could adapt quickly to the NHL.

However, there are also valid concerns. At 5'11" and 179 pounds, Perreault needs to bulk up to withstand the rigors of the NHL. Some worry about his lack of size, but others are confident in his ability to overcome this. He has been working on his strength and quickness. Perreault is also focusing on his defensive game, puck battles, and D-zone coverage to earn his minutes.

The Rangers have a history of mismanaging young forwards, such as Kaapo Kakko and Alexis Lafrenière, by not providing them with consistent roles and opportunities. Giving Perreault a chance in the top six would signal a change in approach and demonstrate a commitment to developing young talent.

Ultimately, the decision rests on whether the Rangers believe Perreault is ready to contribute meaningfully to the team's offense. His skills and potential are undeniable, and fans clearly believe he is the prospect most likely to impact the organization. If the Rangers are willing to be patient and provide him with consistent opportunities, Gabe Perreault could very well become a key player in their top six for years to come.