Home

News

Video

In-Short
Supreme Court: Spouse's secretly recorded private chat admissible as evidence in court proceedings.
  • 207 views
  • 2 min read

The Supreme Court has recently delivered a significant ruling regarding the admissibility of private conversations between spouses as evidence in court. The court clarified that a secretly recorded private conversation between a husband and wife is admissible as evidence, particularly in matrimonial disputes, as long as it doesn't breach privacy rights.

This ruling addresses Section 122 of the Evidence Act, which typically protects marital communications. However, the court emphasized that there are exceptions to this protection to ensure fair trials. The court also acknowledged the role of modern technology in recording conversations, further supporting the admissibility of such evidence.

In the Philippines, a similar stance has been taken regarding digital evidence obtained by private individuals. The Supreme Court of the Philippines has ruled that photos and messages obtained from platforms like Facebook Messenger by private individuals are admissible as evidence in court. This ruling came about in a case involving the Anti-Child Pornography Act, where a chat thread was presented as evidence. The court stated that the right to privacy, as enshrined in the Bill of Rights, is primarily intended to protect citizens from government intrusion and cannot be invoked against private individuals. The court also noted that if an individual shares their password, they lose reasonable expectation of privacy.

Furthermore, the Supreme Court of the Philippines has also addressed the admissibility of online chat logs and videos as evidence in criminal proceedings. The court has stated that using such digital evidence does not violate the right to privacy if it is used to determine whether a crime has been committed. This position aligns with the Data Privacy Act of 2012, which allows for the processing of sensitive personal information when it is necessary to determine criminal liability or to protect the lawful rights and interests of individuals in court proceedings. The Supreme Court has emphasized that the evidence must be presented to assess criminal liability.

However, it's important to note that there are nuances to the admissibility of electronic evidence. Screenshots of group chats are generally admissible in Philippine courts, provided they meet certain criteria, including relevance, proper authentication, and compliance with privacy and wiretap laws. Courts balance the acceptance of digital conversations with safeguards against secret interception and data abuses. To prove that a chat screenshot is genuine, one may need to provide a witness with knowledge, a digital signature, metadata, or expert testimony.

In conclusion, the Supreme Court rulings, both in India and the Philippines, suggest a growing acceptance of privately recorded or obtained digital communications as evidence in legal proceedings, with certain conditions. The key considerations are the context in which the evidence was obtained, the purpose for which it is being used, and the need to balance privacy rights with the pursuit of justice.


Writer - Aahana Patel
Eager and inquisitive, Aahana is a journalist with a passion for local human-interest stories and sports. She's quickly learning the art of interviewing, aiming to amplify the voices of everyday people in her community, and enjoys keeping up with the latest in the sports world. Aahana is committed to ethical reporting and believes in the power of storytelling to connect individuals and foster understanding.
Advertisement

Latest Post


World  |  Jul 15, 2025
A tragic incident occurred at the Chinchoti Waterfall in Vasai, Maharashtra, on Monday, July 14, 2025, where two college students from Mumbai drowned. The victims have been identified as Pralhad Shahjarav, 22, and Sushil Dabhale, 24. According to re...

Sports  |  Jul 15, 2025
The Indiana Fever are set to face the Connecticut Sun in a WNBA matchup. Here's a preview of the game, including injury reports, potential starting lineups, and predictions. **Injury Report** * **Indiana Fever:** DeWanna Bonner is ruled out for p...

Entertainment  |  Jul 15, 2025
John Abraham and his wife, Priya Runchal, have been married since 2014. While they celebrated their 10th wedding anniversary in June 2024, they have not yet started a family. In an old interview, John addressed the reasons behind their decision to no...

Business  |  Jul 15, 2025
HCLTech's stock experienced a decline of 2% following the release of its Q1FY26 earnings report, which revealed a mixed performance and led to divided opinions among analysts regarding the company's outlook. While revenue saw some growth, profit marg...

Advertisement
World  |  Jul 15, 2025
As the SpaceX Dragon spacecraft gracefully undocked from the International Space Station (ISS) on July 14, 2025, Indian astronaut Group Captain Subhanshu Shukla began his journey back to Earth, marking the end of a remarkable chapter in India's space...

Entertainment  |  Jul 15, 2025
"Aankhon Ki Gustaakhiyan," starring Vikrant Massey and Shanaya Kapoor, has experienced a significant drop in box office collections on its fourth day, indicating a failure to pass the Monday test. The romantic drama, directed by Santosh Singh and wri...

Business  |  Jul 15, 2025
Indian government bond yields are anticipated to rise in early trading today, influenced by the Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) recent announcement of another liquidity withdrawal operation, which has weakened market sentiment and suggests policymakers...

Entertainment  |  Jul 15, 2025
Bollywood actress Kriti Sanon recently attended the India vs. England Test match at Lord's Cricket Ground in London, accompanied by rumored boyfriend Kabir Bahia. The couple's appearance together has fueled speculation about their relationship, with ...

Advertisement
About   •   Terms   •   Privacy
© 2025 DailyDigest360