In a recent post on his social media platform, Truth Social, President Donald Trump voiced his desire for the Washington Commanders and Cleveland Guardians to revert to their former names, "Redskins" and "Indians" respectively. This stance reflects Trump's previous criticisms of both teams' decisions to change their names in response to concerns about racial insensitivity.
The Washington Commanders retired the name "Redskins" in 2020 after decades of controversy and pressure from sponsors, Native American groups, and politicians. The team temporarily rebranded as the "Washington Football Team" before adopting the "Commanders" name in 2022. Similarly, the Cleveland Guardians, known as the "Indians" since 1915, changed their name in 2021 following criticism regarding the use of Native American imagery and the term "Indians".
Trump, however, believes these changes are a mistake. He argues that the "great Indian people, in massive numbers, want this to happen," claiming that their "heritage and prestige is systematically being taken away from them". He has also stated that it is more insulting to Native Americans to change the name than to retain it. Trump has previously expressed his opposition to the Commanders' name change, stating that it "doesn't have the same ring" and that the original name had "heritage behind it". He also criticized the Guardians' name change, calling it "such a disgrace".
Trump's stance on this issue aligns with his broader views on cultural and heritage issues. He has often positioned himself as a defender of tradition and has criticized what he sees as attempts to erase or rewrite history. In this context, his support for the "Redskins" and "Indians" names can be seen as a rejection of political correctness and a defense of what he considers to be American heritage. He has even launched a Title VI investigation into New York's attempt to retire Massapequa High School's "Chiefs" mascot and nickname, sending Education Secretary Linda McMahon to speak in support of the name.
Despite Trump's urging, it appears unlikely that either team will revert to its former name. Washington Commanders owner Josh Harris has stated that the "Commanders" brand is here to stay, citing its successful integration into the team's culture. Guardians president of baseball operations Chris Antonetti has also indicated that the team has no plans to revisit the name change, stating that they are "excited about the future" as the Guardians.
The controversy surrounding Native American team names and mascots has been a long-standing issue in the United States. While some argue that these names honor Native American heritage, others view them as offensive and perpetuating harmful stereotypes. This has led to increased pressure on sports teams and schools to change their names and mascots, resulting in a gradual shift away from the use of Native American imagery in sports.