The Edmonton Oilers find themselves at a crossroads regarding their goaltending situation heading into the 2025-26 NHL season, with Stuart Skinner's future particularly uncertain. Despite Skinner's potential and the Oilers' Stanley Cup aspirations, his performance has been inconsistent, leading to speculation about a possible trade before a significant contract extension.
Skinner's play during the 2025 Stanley Cup Finals drew heavy criticism after sub-par goaltending in his last three appearances. While he has shown flashes of brilliance, including outplaying established goalies in previous playoff series, his save percentage of under .900 raises concerns for a team aiming for the Stanley Cup.
Several factors contribute to the swirling trade rumors. Firstly, the Oilers' "win-now" mentality, fueled by consecutive deep playoff runs, demands consistent goaltending. Secondly, Skinner's current contract, with a $2.6 million cap hit, is an "extreme value deal" for a potential starting goalie, making him an attractive trade asset. However, some analysts are suggesting a massive extension from the Oilers for Stuart Skinner could still be in the works.
Several trade scenarios have been proposed. One suggestion involves Skinner being sent to the Buffalo Sabres in exchange for Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen, along with a second-round pick and Beau Akey. Luukkonen, 26, has shown promise and could benefit from playing behind a stronger team like the Oilers. Another scenario involves a trade with the Boston Bruins, potentially for Michael DiPietro. DiPietro, also 26, has dominated in the AHL and may be ready for an NHL opportunity.
However, trading Skinner isn't the only option on the table. Some argue that the Oilers should extend Skinner now, banking on his potential to become a reliable starter. A new goalie coach and a strong defensive structure could help Skinner regain his form. The Oilers' defense is already considered playoff-caliber, ranking high in shots allowed per 60 minutes. If Skinner can improve his consistency, the Oilers may not need to pursue a trade.
Ultimately, the Oilers face a critical decision. They can either gamble on Skinner's potential and offer him a contract extension, or they can explore trade options to bring in a more proven goalie. The organization has little patience for inconsistency, and if Skinner or Pickard falter, the Oilers could aggressively pursue trades or free-agent options to ensure a reliable playoff-ready goalie. The pressure is on for the Oilers to solidify their goaltending situation and give themselves the best chance to compete for the Stanley Cup in the upcoming season.
