Recent reports linking Jonathan Marchessault to the Montreal Canadiens have ignited a flurry of reactions from fans, showcasing a clear divide regarding the potential acquisition. The discussion, sparked by The Athletic's Chris Johnston, centers on whether the 34-year-old Nashville Predators forward would be a good fit for the Canadiens, who are currently undergoing a rebuild.
Johnston's proposition suggests that Marchessault, a Quebec native with a no-movement clause, might welcome a trade to Montreal. The former Conn Smythe Trophy winner could bring valuable experience and offensive capabilities to the Canadiens' youthful roster, potentially filling a top-six role. This season, Marchessault has recorded 7 goals and 3 assists in 27 games.
However, the suggestion has been met with considerable skepticism from Canadiens fans. A primary concern revolves around Marchessault's age and contract. Turning 35 this week, he still has multiple years remaining on his contract with a $5.5 million cap hit. Many fans question the wisdom of acquiring an older, expensive player who isn't a center, especially considering the team's emphasis on youth, flexibility, and internal development. Some fans have even called the narrative "lazy," arguing that a player's Quebecois background shouldn't automatically link them to the Canadiens.
Further complicating matters is the Canadiens' existing roster. With young talents like Nick Suzuki, Cole Caufield, Juraj Slafkovský, and Ivan Demidov already projected in the top six, the addition of Marchessault could limit opportunities for these emerging players.
The financial implications of such a trade are also under scrutiny. To accommodate Marchessault's contract, Montreal would likely need to shed salary, with Patrik Laine's $8.7 million cap hit being the most obvious candidate. Laine has only played five games this season, recording one point, and is currently recovering from hernia surgery performed in October 2025, sidelining him for an expected three to four months.
The possibility of trading Laine, who could become an unrestricted free agent at the end of the 2025-26 season, has further fueled fan apprehension. Some speculate whether the Predators would even be interested in taking on Laine's contract, given his recent injury and performance. Others suggest that the Predators might place Laine on Long-Term Injured Reserve (LTIR).
Despite the backlash, some argue that Marchessault's experience and offensive capabilities could benefit the Canadiens, especially given the injuries the team is facing. Chris Johnston noted that Marchessault would bring experience to one of the NHL's youngest rosters and should be able to add offensive pop to the Habs' top-six forward group. It is also believed that Montreal was interested in Marchessault in the summer of 2024 before he chose Nashville.
Ultimately, whether the Canadiens pursue a trade for Marchessault remains to be seen. Kent Hughes may not be done shopping, but the next "big" transaction will have to fit on all fronts.
