As the Toronto Maple Leafs struggle to find consistency this season, analysts are suggesting General Manager Brad Treliving consider a significant roster shakeup, potentially involving long-time defenseman Morgan Rielly. With the team sitting at the bottom of the Atlantic Division, the pressure is mounting to make impactful changes to re-enter the playoff hunt.
Rielly, 31, is currently in the fourth year of an eight-year, $60 million contract. While he remains a key offensive contributor from the blue line, concerns linger about his defensive play and overall consistency. This season, Rielly has tallied 24 points in 35 games, but his minus-8 rating raises questions about his defensive capabilities. According to some observers, Rielly's defensive "mishaps" are costing the team, and his offensive output isn't enough to compensate.
TSN's Bryan Hayes recently suggested that if the Leafs' struggles continue, exploring a Rielly trade should be a serious consideration, potentially as early as the trade deadline. Hayes noted Rielly's long tenure in Toronto and suggested that both the player and the team might benefit from a change of scenery. While Rielly was approached about his willingness to waive his no-movement clause in the offseason and showed no interest, the team's performance may force Treliving's hand. Trading Rielly would be an interesting proposition, although it is difficult to imagine what the Leafs would be able to get for him at this point.
The Maple Leafs' salary cap situation further complicates the matter. With a projected cap hit of approximately $69.79 million for the 2025-26 season and a salary cap limit of $95.5 million, the team has limited flexibility to add significant pieces without shedding salary. Rielly's $7.5 million cap hit could provide some much-needed breathing room if the Leafs decide to pursue other avenues to improve their roster.
Potential trade partners and the return the Leafs could expect for Rielly remain unclear. Some have speculated about a potential swap with the Edmonton Oilers involving Darnell Nurse, while others suggest targeting a player like Michael Bunting from the Nashville Predators. However, any deal would likely require Rielly's consent, given his no-movement clause.
Despite the trade speculation, Rielly remains a respected figure in the Maple Leafs organization and a popular player among fans. He has been a consistent presence on the team's blue line for over a decade, and his offensive skills are undeniable. However, with the team's Stanley Cup window potentially closing, Treliving may need to make difficult decisions to maximize the team's chances of success.
Ultimately, the decision to trade Rielly will depend on the Maple Leafs' performance in the coming months and Treliving's assessment of the team's long-term needs. If Toronto continues to struggle, a Rielly trade could be a necessary move to retool the roster and create a new path forward.
