The Toronto Maple Leafs find themselves in an unusual position as Anthony Stolarz nears his return from injury: possessing three NHL-caliber goalies. With Joseph Woll and Dennis Hildeby performing well, the Leafs may consider trading Stolarz.
Stolarz, 32, has been sidelined since November 11th due to an upper-body injury sustained in a game against the Boston Bruins. Prior to the injury, Stolarz played 13 games, achieving a 6-5-1 record with an .884 save percentage and a 3.51 goals-against average. This performance marked a decline from his previous season's success. On January 21, 2026, Stolarz was assigned to the Toronto Marlies of the American Hockey League (AHL) on a conditioning loan. Coach Craig Berube stated that there was no set timeline for Stolarz's return from the AHL.
Nick Kypreos of Sportsnet added Stolarz to his trade board, suggesting the Maple Leafs might seriously consider moving him. Kypreos noted that several teams need a goalie, but the options are limited. Stolarz, if healthy, could be a valuable trade chip. Stolarz also has a 16-team no-trade list, potentially limiting Toronto's options.
Several teams could be potential destinations for Stolarz. The Carolina Hurricanes are reportedly seeking a capable goaltender despite leading the Metro Division. With Pyotr Kochetkov out for the season and Frederik Andersen having an off-year, Stolarz could provide crucial insurance in net. A potential trade with Carolina could involve the Maple Leafs acquiring a right-handed defenseman like Sean Walker or Jalen Chatfield. The Ottawa Senators are also struggling with their goaltending. Despite acquiring James Reimer, their overall situation remains uncertain. Stolarz could form a more reliable tandem with Linus Ullmark, assuming Ullmark returns to form. The New Jersey Devils have also been mentioned as a team that could have interest in Stolarz. A proposed trade package involves Stolarz, Dakota Joshua, and Calle Jarnkrok going to New Jersey for Dougie Hamilton and a prospect like Kevan Benjamin or Chase Cheslock.
The Maple Leafs' current priority is to acquire a premium asset, most likely a defenseman or a quality scorer. With limited draft picks and prospects, they may need to be creative in making a deal.
