The New York Islanders have a rich history, filled with legendary players who have donned the blue and orange. Identifying the single "greatest of all time" is a challenging, and ultimately subjective, exercise, sparking debate among fans and analysts alike. However, several names consistently emerge in the conversation, each with a compelling case for the title.
Denis Potvin, a dominant defenseman, often tops the list. Drafted first overall in 1973, Potvin revolutionized the position, blending offensive prowess with physical intensity. He captained the Islanders through their dynasty years, leading them to four consecutive Stanley Cups from 1980 to 1983. Potvin's accolades include three Norris Trophies as the league's best defenseman, and he was the first defenseman to reach 1,000 career points. His impact on the Islanders and the game of hockey is undeniable.
Bryan Trottier, a dynamic two-way forward, is another strong contender. Trottier spent 15 seasons with the Islanders, amassing franchise records for games played (1,123), assists (853), and points (1,353). His versatility and relentless work ethic made him a favorite of coach Al Arbour, who famously stated he wouldn't trade Trottier for Wayne Gretzky. Trottier won the Hart Trophy as league MVP in 1979 and the Conn Smythe Trophy as playoff MVP in 1980.
Mike Bossy, arguably the purest goal scorer in NHL history, also holds a prominent place in Islanders lore. Bossy's incredible scoring touch led him to nine consecutive 50-goal seasons, a record unmatched in the league. He holds the highest goals-per-game average in NHL history and was a key component of the Islanders' dynasty. Bossy's career was cut short by a back injury, but his impact on the game remains significant.
Goaltender Billy Smith, known for his competitiveness and fiery demeanor, backstopped the Islanders to their four Stanley Cups. Smith holds the franchise record for games played and wins by a goaltender and won the Vezina Trophy in 1982. His performance in the 1983 Stanley Cup Final, where he shut down Wayne Gretzky and the Edmonton Oilers, solidified his place in Islanders history.
Other notable Islanders legends include Clark Gillies, a power forward who brought toughness and skill to the team; Bob Nystrom, known as "Mr. Islander" for his dedication and clutch performances, and Butch Goring, who was considered the final piece needed for the Islanders' first Stanley Cup. All had their numbers retired by the organization.
Ultimately, the "greatest of all time" title is a matter of personal preference. Each of these players contributed significantly to the Islanders' success and left an indelible mark on the franchise. Whether it's Potvin's dominance, Trottier's versatility, Bossy's scoring touch, or Smith's goaltending heroics, the New York Islanders' history is filled with greatness.