The New Jersey Devils' 2025-26 season has been turbulent, and recent comments from star forward Jack Hughes have stirred up strong reactions from the fanbase. The team, which had high expectations coming into the season, is struggling to stay in playoff contention.

Hughes addressed the team's struggles and the fans' frustrations at a Devils Youth Foundation event on Monday. When asked what his message was to fans who might be losing hope, Hughes responded, "I honestly have nothing to say to them. Honestly, like for us, it's just our group. We've got to figure out a way to win more hockey games... it is on us".

These remarks quickly spread online, igniting a debate among Devils fans. Some interpreted Hughes' words as a sign that he was dismissive of the fanbase's concerns, while others defended him, suggesting he was simply emphasizing the team's responsibility to improve. Critics on social media expressed disappointment, with some saying they had "lost a lot of respect" for Hughes. Some fans voiced their frustration with the team's performance and Hughes' inability to stay healthy.

Conversely, Hughes has also received support. Some argue that his comments were honest and that he shouldn't be expected to offer platitudes when the team is underperforming. These supporters believe Hughes is right to focus on the team's internal issues and the need for the players to take ownership of their performance. Some have also pointed out that Hughes has expressed his appreciation for the Devils fans in the past. In September 2025, Hughes said, "We've got great fans. I love how much they have my back... I think this fanbase loves me and I love playing here. It's special".

Hughes' commitment to the Devils has also been questioned by fans due to the number of games he has missed due to injuries. Of the seven seasons he has been with the team, he has missed significant time, 20+ games, in five of them. Despite these concerns, when Hughes is healthy, he is one of the most dynamic players in the game. This season, he has recorded 36 points (12 goals, 24 assists) in 36 games.

As the Devils approach the Olympic break, the controversy surrounding Hughes' comments underscores the tension between the team and its fanbase. With the team struggling to meet expectations, the pressure is on Hughes and his teammates to turn things around in the final stretch of the season.