Home

News

Video

In-Short
President Murmu Seeks Supreme Court Clarity: Can Deadlines Be Imposed on Presidential/Gubernatorial Assent to Legislation?
  • 415 views
  • 2 min read

President Droupadi Murmu has recently engaged the Supreme Court of India, questioning the constitutional validity of setting deadlines for Governors and the President to decide on state bills. This move comes after the Supreme Court's April 8 verdict, which fixed timelines for Governors and the President to act on state bills, a decision made in response to delays in assenting to bills by the Tamil Nadu Governor.

President Murmu invoked Article 143(1) of the Constitution, seeking the Supreme Court's opinion on 14 questions, asserting that the Constitution does not prescribe any timeframe for presidential action once a bill is presented for assent. She raised concerns about the court's overreach and deemed the concept of "deemed assent" as alien to the constitutional framework. According to the President, Articles 200 and 201, which apply to Governors and the President respectively, lack stipulations regarding timelines or procedures for granting or refusing assent to bills passed by a state assembly. She emphasized that the discretion exercised by Governors and the President under these articles is governed by "polycentric considerations," including federalism, uniformity of laws, national integrity, and the doctrine of separation of powers.

The Supreme Court's April 8 verdict prescribed specific timelines for Governors, including one month for withholding assent, three months for withholding assent contrary to the advice of the State Cabinet, and one month for bills presented for reconsideration. The court also set a three-month deadline for the President to decide on bills reserved for consideration by the Governor. The Supreme Court bench, comprising Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, asserted that Governors must act on the aid and advice of the council of ministers, without independent discretion, and cannot indefinitely delay action on bills. The court also clarified that there is no concept of "absolute veto" or "pocket veto" available to the Governors.

The President's reference raises critical questions about the balance of power between the executive and the judiciary, and the extent to which courts can impose timelines on constitutional authorities when the Constitution itself is silent. The Supreme Court has in the past held conflicting views on the justiciability of presidential assent to bills, prompting the President to seek clarity on the matter. The court's recent ruling was triggered by Tamil Nadu Governor R.N. Ravi's delay in assenting to 10 bills, which the court termed "erroneous in law". The court emphasized that Governors are constitutional heads and not political actors, and their actions should not obstruct the legislative process.

The Supreme Court's imposition of timelines on Governors and the President aims to curb the misuse of gubernatorial powers and ensure accountability in constitutional governance. The court has clarified that while Article 200 does not specify a time limit, this silence cannot be interpreted as a license for indefinite inaction. The Supreme Court has also stated that any delay or misuse of discretion by the Governor is subject to judicial review.

This move by President Murmu highlights the ongoing tensions between the judiciary and the executive, particularly concerning the powers of Governors in states. The Supreme Court's opinion on the matter will have significant implications for Centre-State relations and the functioning of Indian democracy.


Writer - Aahana Patel
Eager and inquisitive, Aahana is a journalist with a passion for local human-interest stories and sports. She's quickly learning the art of interviewing, aiming to amplify the voices of everyday people in her community, and enjoys keeping up with the latest in the sports world. Aahana is committed to ethical reporting and believes in the power of storytelling to connect individuals and foster understanding.
Advertisement

Latest Post


Entertainment  |  Jun 25, 2025
The premiere of "Maa," the upcoming horror drama featuring Kajol and produced by Ajay Devgn, was a star-studded affair held in Mumbai on June 25, 2025. The event drew a large crowd of Bollywood celebrities and industry personalities, all eager to sup...

Technology  |  Jun 25, 2025
The recent launch and subsequent inflows into spot Ethereum (ETH) exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in the United States have been undeniably impressive, but a deeper dive into Ether futures data suggests that traders are approaching the market with a deg...

Sports  |  Jun 25, 2025
John McEnroe believes the burgeoning rivalry between Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner could reach even greater heights with the emergence of another young star to challenge their dominance. Fresh off their epic French Open final, Alcaraz and Sinner a...

Sports  |  Jun 25, 2025
Following Manchester City's recent Champions League defeat against Juventus, Pep Guardiola has acknowledged the challenges his team faces. The match, which saw Juventus secure a 2-0 victory, has left City in a precarious position in the Champions Lea...

Advertisement
Sports  |  Jun 25, 2025
The Vancouver Canucks and their star goaltender, Thatcher Demko, appear to be heading toward a contract extension, making a potential trade increasingly unlikely. Several reports from reliable sources suggest that negotiations are progressing positiv...

Sports  |  Jun 25, 2025
The expanded FIFA Club World Cup 2025 is underway in the United States, and the group stage is nearing its conclusion. The tournament, featuring 32 teams from six confederations, is seeing intense competition as clubs vie for a spot in the knockout r...

Video Broadcast  |  Jun 25, 2025
India's space program has achieved a significant milestone with the successful co-launch with the United States, signaling a new era of collaboration and ambition in space exploration. The launch, part of the Axiom Mission 4 (Ax-4), carried Indian as...

Sports  |  Jun 25, 2025
The Vegas Golden Knights have secured the services of veteran forward Reilly Smith for another year, signing him to a one-year, $2 million contract extension. This move ensures that Smith, a key member of the original Golden Knights squad, will remai...

Advertisement
About   •   Terms   •   Privacy
© 2025 DailyDigest360