With the potential departure of Mitch Marner looming over the Toronto Maple Leafs, speculation is rife about who could fill the void left by the star winger. Marner, who has been a fixture in Toronto's top six for years, may be seeking a fresh start, potentially in the Western Conference, leaving a significant hole in the Leafs' offensive lineup. As such, the team is now evaluating potential replacements via trade to keep their Stanley Cup aspirations alive.

One name frequently mentioned as a potential target is Jason Robertson of the Dallas Stars. The Stars may be looking to shake things up after another disappointing playoff run, and Robertson, with one year remaining on his very team-friendly contract, could be a valuable trade chip. Robertson has consistently demonstrated his scoring prowess, and his addition would provide a much-needed offensive boost to the Maple Leafs. Furthermore, the presence of his brother, Nick Robertson, on the Leafs roster could incentivize the move. However, acquiring Robertson wouldn't be easy, as the Maple Leafs have limited top prospects and are without a first-round pick for the next three years, creating hurdles to overcome in a potential trade.

Another intriguing possibility is Chris Kreider from the New York Rangers. Kreider, a former 50-goal scorer, brings a combination of skill and physicality that could be a valuable asset to the Leafs. The Rangers, facing their own cap constraints, might be willing to part with Kreider, and the Leafs could capitalize on this opportunity. While Kreider is on the older side, his experience and ability to contribute offensively and on the penalty kill could make him a worthwhile addition.

Beyond specific players, the Maple Leafs might also consider a broader approach to replace Marner, focusing on altering the team's overall composition rather than seeking a direct replacement. This could involve acquiring multiple players who bring different skill sets to the team, such as increased physicality, defensive responsibility, or playmaking ability. This approach would aim to diversify the Leafs' offensive attack and make them a more difficult team to play against.

The Vegas Golden Knights have also emerged as a potential trade partner, with discussions dating back to the summer of 2024. One potential deal that was considered involved sending Marner to Vegas in exchange for Shea Theodore, a defenseman the Leafs coveted. While that particular trade never materialized, the Golden Knights' interest in Marner remains, and a deal could be revisited. Another suggested trade involves William Karlsson and a 2026 second-round pick going to Toronto in exchange for Marner and a sixth-round pick.

Ultimately, the Maple Leafs' approach to replacing Mitch Marner will depend on a variety of factors, including Marner's ultimate decision, the availability of potential trade targets, and the team's overall strategy for the future.