The lack of Pakistani films depicting the reality of Lyari's gang violence stems from the enduring influence of those who were behind the violence, according to sources within the Pakistani film industry. Despite the passage of time, these power structures continue to cast a shadow, making it difficult for filmmakers to explore the subject matter without facing potential repercussions.
Lyari, a densely populated area of Karachi, has a long and troubled history marked by gang warfare, political manipulation, and socio-economic struggles. For decades, it served as a stronghold for various criminal groups, whose activities deeply affected the lives of its residents. These gangs, often backed by political entities, wielded considerable power, engaging in extortion, drug trafficking, and violent clashes.
Several attempts have been made to portray Lyari's complexities on screen, but a comprehensive and honest cinematic representation remains elusive. Some argue that this is because those who benefited from the violence, or were complicit in it, still hold positions of influence in politics, business, and even law enforcement. This creates a chilling effect, discouraging filmmakers from delving too deeply into the issue.
The recently released Indian film "Dhurandhar," set in Lyari, has ignited debate in Pakistan, with some criticizing its depiction of the area as overly negative and propaganda-driven. Sindh Minister Sharjeel Inam Memon, for example, stated that "Lyari should not be associated with violence, stressing that the area represents culture, peace, talent and resilience". He also announced the upcoming release of a Pakistani film, "Mera Lyari," which aims to showcase the locality's "true face," emphasizing peace and prosperity.
However, others argue that glossing over Lyari's violent past does a disservice to the victims and prevents a true understanding of the challenges the community faces. They believe that a film that honestly portrays the gang wars and their underlying causes is necessary to foster healing and promote lasting change.
The reluctance to create such a film highlights the complexities of dealing with sensitive issues in a society where power dynamics are often skewed. Filmmakers may fear censorship, financial constraints, or even threats to their safety if they dare to challenge the established narrative. As a result, the stories of Lyari's victims and the full truth about its past remain largely untold on the silver screen.
The debate surrounding "Dhurandhar" and the promise of "Mera Lyari" underscore the need for nuanced and responsible storytelling when addressing complex social issues. While it is important to showcase the positive aspects of Lyari, such as its rich culture and resilient people, it is equally crucial to acknowledge and confront the painful realities of its past. Only then can the community move forward and build a more peaceful and prosperous future.
Ultimately, whether a Pakistani film can be made that accurately reflects the Lyari's history depends on whether those in power are willing to allow a truthful and uncensored account to be told. Until then, the stories of Lyari will remain shrouded in silence, and the wounds of the past will continue to fester.
