Kartik Aaryan's recent dance performance to the iconic song "Saajanji Ghar Aaye" in the film Tu Meri Main Tera Main Tera Tu Meri has sparked a significant debate on social media. The film, which also stars Ananya Panday, was released on Christmas Day and has already stirred conversation with its recreation of the classic song "Saat Samundar Paar".
A video clip showing Aaryan dancing to "Saajanji Ghar Aaye," a song originally picturized on Salman Khan and Kajol in Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, quickly went viral. In the scene, Aaryan makes a grand entrance at a function, later joined by Panday, and the two dance together.
However, the online reaction has been largely critical. Many social media users have expressed disappointment, with several stating that Aaryan failed to capture the original charm and charisma associated with Salman Khan's performance. Comparisons between Aaryan's rendition and the original have flooded social media, highlighting the challenge of recreating iconic Bollywood moments.
Comments suggest that a significant portion of the online audience was not impressed, referencing the nostalgic appeal of the original song as a key point of comparison. Some felt that the energy and charisma of the original were missing, while others appreciated the attempt to pay homage to a Bollywood classic. This divide in opinion underscores how emotionally invested fans are in these iconic numbers.
Users expressed their opinions with comments like, "Oooo bhai khuda k waastay tu kisi ko bhi copy ker mager salman bhai ko chor dey...(sic)," and "Bhai jaan ke takar me koi nahi hai (sic)". Another user wrote, "Beta tum se na ho payega bhai.ki baat alag hai (sic)". Some comments even accused the film of unnecessarily remixing or reusing iconic songs, calling the trend tiring and unoriginal. One user quipped that Kartik should change his name to "Copycat".
The choreography, set design, and overall presentation have been dissected by fans and critics alike, with many drawing comparisons to the original sequence from Kuch Kuch Hota Hai. The reactions point to a sense of disappointment, as users noted the challenges of recreating an iconic moment from Bollywood music history.
This isn't the first time the film Tu Meri Main Tera Main Tera Tu Meri has faced scrutiny for revisiting classic songs. The remake of "Saat Samundar Paar" had already received attention, with some suggesting that it impacted the film's overall reception. The film is being called out for ruining iconic songs.
The debate surrounding Kartik Aaryan's "Saajanji Ghar Aaye" performance highlights the challenges and potential pitfalls of remaking or reinterpreting beloved Bollywood classics. While some appreciate the homage, many feel that certain iconic performances are best left untouched.
