The Edmonton Oilers' goaltending situation has been a rollercoaster this season, prompting them to explore all available options, including the potential addition of veteran Marc-André Fleury. While the fit seems intriguing on the surface, several objections have been raised regarding the feasibility and wisdom of such a move. Let's address the three biggest concerns surrounding Fleury potentially joining the Oilers.

1. Fleury's Age and Recent Retirement

At 41 years old, and fresh off retirement after the 2024-25 season, Fleury's ability to perform at a high level is a legitimate concern. While he displayed flashes of brilliance during his time with the Minnesota Wild, posting a .899 save percentage in 26 games last season, there's no guarantee he can maintain that form after a period of inactivity. Father Time remains undefeated, and expecting Fleury to be a long-term solution or carry a heavy workload might be unrealistic.

However, Fleury's experience and hockey IQ could still be valuable assets. The Oilers might not need him to be a workhorse, but rather a stabilizing presence who can provide quality starts and mentor the team's other goalies. Moreover, reports suggest that Fleury is open to a return to the NHL, indicating that he believes he still has something to offer. Ultimately, his performance in potential training and conditioning stints would be the true litmus test of his readiness.

2. The Oilers' Existing Goaltending Situation

Edmonton has already made a significant move to address their goaltending woes by acquiring Tristan Jarry from the Pittsburgh Penguins. However, Jarry is currently sidelined with an injury, leaving the Oilers with Calvin Pickard and Connor Ingram. While Ingram has shown promise, the Oilers' team save percentage remains among the league's lowest.

Bringing in Fleury could be viewed as an admission that the Jarry acquisition hasn't solved their problems. It could also create a crowded crease and potentially disrupt team chemistry. However, with Jarry's injury history and the inconsistent play of the other netminders, Fleury could provide much-needed depth and competition. Frank Seravalli of Daily Faceoff believes that the Oilers have the best chance to sign Fleury because of this. Furthermore, Fleury and Jarry were previously teammates in Pittsburgh, which could ease the transition and create a positive dynamic.

3. Fleury's Potential Contract Demands and Trade Cost

As a three-time Stanley Cup champion and future Hall of Famer, Fleury won't come cheap. Even if he's willing to take a reduced salary to join a contender, the Oilers would still need to clear cap space to accommodate him. If a trade is involved, the Oilers might have to part with valuable assets, which could hinder their ability to address other needs.

However, the potential benefits of adding Fleury might outweigh the costs. His experience, leadership, and potential to elevate the team's performance could be invaluable in a playoff run. Oilers General Manager Stan Bowman also has a history with Fleury, having acquired him while with the Chicago Blackhawks, which could facilitate negotiations.

In conclusion, while there are valid concerns surrounding the possibility of Marc-André Fleury joining the Edmonton Oilers, the potential rewards might be too significant to ignore. If Fleury is healthy, motivated, and willing to accept a reasonable contract, he could be the missing piece that helps the Oilers achieve their Stanley Cup aspirations. The next few weeks will be crucial in determining whether this intriguing scenario becomes a reality.