Matthew Robertson has emerged as a pleasant surprise for the New York Rangers during the 2025-26 NHL season. Drafted in the second round (49th overall) of the 2019 NHL Entry Draft, the young defenseman has finally solidified his place on the Rangers' roster, showcasing the reliability the team has been seeking. After spending considerable time in the AHL with the Hartford Wolf Pack, Robertson's patience and perseverance have paid off.

Robertson's journey to the NHL wasn't without its challenges. He spent six years in the Rangers' system, playing 250 games in the AHL. Despite being considered a top prospect at one point, inconsistent growth and injuries hindered his development. There was even a question of whether he would receive a contract offer after his entry-level deal expired. However, he signed a two-year contract with the Rangers.

This season, Robertson has not only made the team but has also become a fixture on the bottom pairing under coach Mike Sullivan. While averaging a little under 16 minutes of ice time per game in a somewhat sheltered role, the 6'4" Edmonton native is making the most of his opportunities.

Robertson's offensive contributions have also exceeded expectations. In 36 games this season, he has two goals and six assists. While not considered an offensive defenseman, his scoring touch has provided unexpected value to the team.

Robertson's strong play has been particularly noticeable since Adam Fox's injury. In December, Robertson logged significant minutes and demonstrated impressive statistics, including a 65.19 GF%, a 55.24 CF%, and a 57.25 xGF%. During that stretch, the team allowed just 1.46 goals against per 60 minutes with Robertson on the ice, a welcome development for the Rangers.

Despite his solid performance, the Rangers' coaching staff opted to scratch Robertson from the lineup for a game against the Utah Mammoth. This decision sparked outrage among fans, especially after Robertson led all Rangers defensemen in ice time during the 2026 Winter Classic, logging 21:50 in a 5-1 victory over the Florida Panthers. Sullivan cited a desire for a "calmer third pair" and Utah's fast-paced game as reasons for the lineup change.

While the decision to scratch Robertson after his Winter Classic performance was met with criticism, his overall performance this season has been a major boost to the New York Rangers. He has proven to be a reliable and valuable asset on the blue line.