In recent news, the Supreme Court addressed the issue of vigilante actions, emphasizing the responsibility of state governments to act against violence and uphold the rule of law. The court's remarks came during a hearing regarding the film "Thug Life," which faced obstruction in Karnataka due to protests and threats from fringe organizations.
The Supreme Court has made it clear that state governments cannot yield to pressure from vigilante groups or allow them to disrupt law and order. The court underscored that it is the duty of the state to maintain law and order and to ensure the safety and security of all citizens. This includes protecting freedom of expression and preventing groups from taking the law into their own hands.
During the proceedings, a bench of Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Manmohan addressed the issue of threats to free speech and the state's role in protecting it. The court expressed concern over instances where artistic expression, such as films, stand-up comedy shows, or poetry recitals, are stifled due to perceived offense or threats of violence.
The specific case that brought this issue to the forefront was the controversy surrounding Kamal Haasan's film "Thug Life" in Karnataka. Despite having certification from the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC), the film's release faced hurdles due to protests and threats from fringe groups who objected to statements made by Haasan. The court firmly stated that once a film has been certified by the CBFC, it is the state government's responsibility to ensure its smooth release and protect theaters from any potential violence or disruption.
The Supreme Court has directed the Karnataka government to take action against those obstructing the screening of "Thug Life" and to ensure the film's release. The state government has assured the court that it will provide adequate security to theaters and take necessary measures to prevent any untoward incidents. The court also made it clear that it did not want situations where someone's sentiments are hurt by statements, leading to the film's release being stopped, a stand-up show being cancelled, or an artist being prevented from performing.
The Supreme Court's intervention in the "Thug Life" case highlights the importance of protecting freedom of expression and upholding the rule of law. The court has sent a strong message to state governments that they cannot allow vigilante groups to dictate what can and cannot be shown or expressed. The responsibility lies with the state to maintain law and order and to ensure that all citizens can exercise their fundamental rights without fear of violence or intimidation. The court has also made it clear that it will not issue guidelines for future incidents, but expects state governments to take action based on existing laws and constitutional principles.
