Crystal Palace's qualification for the Europa League, a historic achievement celebrated after their FA Cup victory against Manchester City, is now under serious threat. This predicament arises from the increasingly complex world of multi-club ownership (MCO) and UEFA's regulations designed to safeguard the integrity of its competitions. At the heart of the issue is John Textor, who holds a 43% stake in Crystal Palace through his Eagle Football Holdings, while also owning a majority stake in French club Lyon.
UEFA rules explicitly prevent any individual or entity from having "control or influence" over more than one club participating in the same European competition. The concern is to prevent conflicts of interest and ensure fair play. With both Crystal Palace and Lyon qualifying for the Europa League, UEFA is scrutinizing Textor's position to determine whether he exerts undue influence over both clubs.
Palace argues that Textor's voting rights are limited to 25%, equivalent to those of chairman Steve Parish and co-owners Josh Harris and David Blitzer, therefore, he does not have decisive control over the club's operations. They emphasize that Palace and Lyon are run independently, with no shared facilities, assets, staff, or player movement between the two clubs. Steve Parish remains the key decision maker.
UEFA's stance is that any party with at least 30% of voting power has 'decisive influence' over a club. If UEFA deems Textor's influence too significant, Crystal Palace risks being barred from the Europa League. This would be a cruel blow for the club and its fans, who are eagerly anticipating their first major European campaign in over two decades.
The situation is further complicated by the precedent set by other multi-club ownership groups. Cases involving Manchester City and Girona, Manchester United and Nice, and Chelsea and Strasbourg have raised questions about the consistency and fairness of UEFA's approach to MCO regulations. Some argue that UEFA seems more lenient towards larger, more influential clubs, while smaller clubs face stricter enforcement.
Adding another layer to the turmoil, Nottingham Forest reportedly voiced concerns to UEFA regarding Crystal Palace's eligibility, with Nottingham potentially benefiting should Palace be excluded.
The stakes are high for Crystal Palace. A ban from the Europa League would not only deny them a historic opportunity but also have financial and reputational consequences. The club is doing everything it can to convince UEFA of its compliance and preserve its place in the competition. One potential solution on the table is Textor selling his stake in Crystal Palace. He has reportedly offered his shares to his co-owners for around £170 million.
The outcome of this situation remains uncertain. Crystal Palace have appealed the decision to the Court of Arbitration for Sport. As UEFA deliberates, the club and its fans are left in a state of suspense, hoping that their dream of European football will not be snatched away due to the complexities of multi-club ownership and the looming threat of a court battle.