The Toronto Maple Leafs face a familiar dilemma as the trade deadline approaches: whether to cash in on a valuable asset or risk losing him for nothing. This time, the player in question is Bobby McMann, a versatile forward who has become an integral part of the team.

McMann's journey to the NHL is a testament to perseverance. Undrafted, he honed his skills at Colgate University before signing with the Maple Leafs as a free agent in April 2022. After overcoming a lower-body injury that hampered his 2023-24 training camp, he proved his mettle, earning a call-up to the Leafs and showcasing his offensive capabilities. McMann has solidified his role this season, contributing 19 goals and 13 assists. His blend of speed, grit, and scoring touch makes him a valuable asset.

However, McMann's impending unrestricted free agency presents a challenge for the Leafs. With the team's Stanley Cup aspirations and limited cap space, General Manager Brad Treliving must weigh the potential return from trading McMann against the value he brings to the roster.

Several factors complicate the decision. McMann's current $950,000 contract makes him an attractive target for teams seeking a cost-effective boost to their forward ranks. His versatility allows him to play in various roles, increasing his appeal to potential suitors. However, the Leafs also recognize the difficulty of acquiring players of McMann's caliber mid-season, especially given the rising trade costs.

The risk of losing McMann for nothing in free agency is a significant concern. If the Leafs believe they cannot re-sign him, trading him before the deadline would be a prudent move to acquire assets for the future. However, trading McMann would create a hole in the Leafs' lineup, potentially impacting their playoff push. Finding a suitable replacement with similar attributes and affordability would be a challenge.

Ultimately, the decision on McMann's future rests with Treliving. He must assess the team's Stanley Cup window, evaluate McMann's potential trade value, and consider the long-term implications of his choice. A misstep could haunt the Maple Leafs, either by losing a valuable player for nothing or by weakening their roster in a crucial season. As the trade deadline looms, the Leafs must tread carefully to avoid another blunder.