West Indies coach Daren Sammy has ignited a crucial conversation about the state of first-class cricket in the Caribbean, just ahead of their Test series against Australia, beginning June 25, 2025. Sammy's critique centers on what he views as a flawed system where players with modest averages are deemed indispensable, ultimately hindering the team's pursuit of success. His comments, made during an interview on QFM Dominica, highlight a data-driven approach to selection while underscoring the unhealthy state of the regional cricket framework.
Sammy emphasized that selecting players based on consistently low averages sets a concerning precedent. He explicitly stated that "averages of 25 will not bring us success," suggesting that such acceptance undermines the pursuit of excellence necessary for competing at the international level. This statement comes in the context of recent team selections where players like Kavem Hodge and Alick Athanaze, who played significant roles in the West Indies' 2023-25 World Test Championship campaign, have been dropped. Hodge has 556 runs in 11 Tests with an average of 25, while Athanaze has a similar average from 13 Tests.
Sammy clarified that these players are not permanently excluded but warned against glorifying mediocrity. He pointed out that both Hodge and Athanaze participated in the 'A' team series, indicating their continued presence in the selection pool. However, he stressed that the current team direction and the roles defined by data analysis do not align with their performance levels at this time. Sammy’s analytical approach involved studying the top three teams in the world, evaluating batting positions, and comparing them to the West Indies' performance.
The coach's remarks reflect a broader concern about the development pathways for cricketers in the West Indies. A persistent challenge is the attraction of promising players to lucrative T20 leagues like the Indian Premier League (IPL), which can lead to a decline in performance and team cohesion in international formats. This issue, coupled with administrative challenges and historical imbalances in batting and bowling, has contributed to the team's struggles. Sammy's emphasis on data-driven strategies, skill development, tactical adjustments, and careful personnel selection signals a commitment to addressing these underlying issues.
Despite the challenges, there are promising signs. Uncapped player Kevlon Anderson, who has an average above 40, has joined the squad, indicating a focus on rewarding high performance in first-class cricket. Sammy's strategy also includes analyzing data from regional first-class cricket and assessing West Indies' performances over the past few years to align strategies effectively.
Sammy's vision extends beyond immediate results. He aims to foster a culture of excellence, emphasizing national pride and fan loyalty while acknowledging the realities of the modern game. He recognizes the need for open communication with players, ensuring they understand the reasons behind selection decisions, and aims to rebuild trust in the Cricket West Indies (CWI) institution. He also aims to improve the Test pacers' economy rates to put pressure on opposing batters. Sammy's long-term goals involve elevating the team's status on the global stage through a realistic and data-driven approach.
