Mohammad Rizwan, the Pakistani wicket-keeper batsman, is facing heavy criticism after a controversial "retired out" decision during a Big Bash League (BBL) match between his team, the Melbourne Renegades, and the Sydney Thunder. The incident has sparked a debate about player treatment and respect within the league, with many calling for a reevaluation of how players are managed.
Rizwan, who has been under scrutiny for his strike rate in the T20 format, scored 26 runs off 23 balls before being asked by Renegades captain Will Sutherland to leave the field. Sutherland himself was run out shortly after, adding fuel to the fire. The move, intended to accelerate the innings, backfired and triggered a wave of disapproval, particularly from Pakistani cricket fans and former players. Many viewed the decision as disrespectful and humiliating for a player of Rizwan's stature, with some suggesting he should withdraw from the league in protest.
Former Pakistan wicket-keeper Kamran Akmal weighed in on the situation, stating that the treatment of Rizwan had caused "mockery" and "a sense of humiliation". During a discussion on GTV Sports, Akmal referenced Younis Khan's stand against being benched in the IPL, implying that Rizwan should consider a similar stance. Akmal also acknowledged the evolving nature of T20 cricket, where teams often prioritize momentum and scoring rate over individual reputation. He urged Rizwan to adapt his playing style to meet the demands of the modern game.
Despite the criticism, some Australian cricket figures have defended the Renegades' decision. Former Australia all-rounder Shane Watson acknowledged the potential ego hit but emphasized the coach's role in managing the situation. Former Pakistan coach Jason Gillespie supported the decision, posting "100% right decision" on X.
Rizwan's BBL season has been underwhelming, with just 167 runs in eight innings at an average of 20.87 and a strike rate of 101.82. This has further intensified the debate surrounding his approach to T20 cricket. Some Pakistani fans believe that Rizwan, along with Babar Azam and Shaheen Afridi, have been "exposed" in the BBL after being overhyped.
The incident has highlighted the pressure faced by international players in franchise leagues and the need for them to adapt to the fast-paced nature of T20 cricket. While some defend the tactical nature of the decision, others argue that it sets a bad precedent for player treatment. The Melbourne Renegades will face the Perth Scorchers on January 15, 2026, at Docklands Stadium in Melbourne. The Sydney Thunder, who were involved in the game where Rizwan was retired out, are looking to build momentum in the BBL 2025-26 season.
