Following Manchester United's recent 2-1 defeat to Aston Villa, club legend Roy Keane has delivered a scathing assessment of the team's performance, particularly singling out the players for failing to take responsibility. Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports after the game on December 21, 2025, Keane didn't hold back in his criticism, emphasizing the need for players to "roll their sleeves up" and be accountable, rather than constantly shifting blame to the manager.
The defeat, which saw Morgan Rogers score twice for Aston Villa with Matheus Cunha responding for United, leaves the Red Devils in seventh place in the Premier League, further diminishing their chances of securing Champions League football next season. Keane expressed his disappointment with the team's lack of fight and highlighted individual errors that led to the goals conceded. He was particularly critical of Diogo Dalot's performance, stating that he "doesn't do enough" and suggesting that he was at fault for Rogers' first goal.
"You can have all the talent in the world, but you have to roll your sleeves up and when the game gets a bit tight you say you're going to do your bit for the team," Keane said. "There are too many players who don't do enough. Not just [Diogo] Dalot". Keane also said, "Out of possession they're one of the worst teams in the league. With the ball they're good, but if you want to be a top footballer, it's about what you do out of possession".
Keane pointed to Rogers' opening goal as a prime example of United's shortcomings, questioning whether the players recognized the danger. He lamented the team's inability to "do the ugly bits" of football, which he believes are essential for any top team. Keane stated that United "cut corners, take too many risks and I'm glad they get punished". He added that he likes "to see teams getting punished who take chances and let their team-mates and fans down".
Adding to United's woes, Bruno Fernandes sustained an injury during the match, potentially sidelining him for the busy holiday period. Peter Schmeichel, another United legend, has warned that Fernandes' absence could be a "massive problem" for the team, highlighting his importance as a leader and key performer. With other players unavailable, including Kobbie Mainoo, it may open the door for academy players to get minutes.
Keane's criticism extends beyond just this single game, reflecting a broader concern about the culture and mentality within the Manchester United squad. He believes that until the players take greater responsibility and demonstrate a willingness to work harder, the team will continue to struggle. He went as far to say he was "glad" his former club was "getting punished".
